End of the IACHR case for former San Francisco judge Washington Espino
After more than two decades, the process of former San Francisco de Macorís judge Washington Espino against the Dominican State at the IACHR comes to an end.

Our people from San Francisco de Macorís always keep the issues of our homeland close to their hearts, and today we turn our gaze toward a major institutional event involving a well-known judicial servant from our Duarte province. After a long journey spanning over twenty years, the former judge of the San Francisco Labor Court, Washington David Espino Muñoz, has announced the definitive closure of the process he brought before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights.
The history of this case file began in April 2004, when the magistrate filed his formal petition. It all stemmed from his fourteen-month suspension without pay, culminating in his dismissal from the justice system in December 2004, after nine years of serving justice in our region. Years later, in 2017, the international body admitted the request to examine the merits of the situation.
The turning point came with Merits Report No. 107/23, dated July 20, 2023. In that document, the Commission determined that the Dominican State violated the judicial guarantees, judicial protection, and political rights of the former San Francisco judge, both through the prior unpaid suspension measure and the disciplinary process that led to his removal from office.
Given this scenario, the international entity issued recommendations aimed at the full reparation of the damages caused and the implementation of safeguards so that disciplinary procedures against magistrates comply with international standards of due process. As a gesture of moral redress, the Council of the Judiciary unanimously approved including a mention of the report in Judicial Bulletin No. 1129, corresponding to December 2004, specifically on page 12.
Likewise, reparation agreements were finalized with both the Judiciary and the Dominican State, complying with the IACHR guidelines. Regarding the financial aspects, the former judge himself clarified in his statement that the central purpose was never tied to money, but rather to the defense of the rule of law, also highlighting that all documentation has been made available for academic purposes, having served as a reference in over sixty cases within the inter-American system.
For our San Francisco community and for all Dominicans living abroad, news like this reminds us of the importance of justice, professional dignity, and perseverance in defending fundamental rights. Seeing a man from our homeland succeed in getting the violation of his procedural guarantees recognized after two decades of struggle is an event that transcends local borders.
It is worth keeping a close eye on how these types of international precedents impact reforms in the Dominican judicial system and respect for due process for public servants. The closing of this cycle, announced by the magistrate without grudges and with a spirit of gratitude, marks a historic milestone etched into the institutional memory of our Duarte province and the entire Dominican Republic.


